Substantial progress has been made both at a regional and international level. Cultural rights in the case law of the international court. Preah vihear remained under thai occupation until the early 1960s when the international court of justice upheld cambodian sovereignty leifer, 196162. A legal view of the case of the temple preah vihear. A complete guide through text and photographs to this magnificent cambodian temple. Thesis submitted in partial fufillment of the requirements for the degree of master of arts in international affairs unesco and the preah vihear dispute. Further, maps showing preah vihear to be on the cambodian side were printed in thailand. The temple and the grounds are of considerable artistic and archaeological interest, and are potenti. It found that the territory on which the temple of preah vihear was situated belonged to cambodia and by a vote of nine to three that thailand was under an obligation to withdraw all its personnel at the temple and in the vicinity thereof in cambodian territory. On 18 july 2011, the international court of justice indicated provisional measures with regard to the temple of preah vihear dispute between cambodia and thailand.
The uns top court has ruled that most of the disputed land around a flashpoint ancient temple on the thai border belongs to cambodia and that thai security forces should leave. It was expected that the decision would stop the border conflict between thailand and cambodia. Icj interpretation of the temple of preah vihear judgment. In october 1961, the dispute led to a suspension of diplomatic relations and the closing of the thaicambodian border.
Preah vihear river books guides english and thai edition. But it is precisely the fact that thailand had raised these other questions, but not that of preah vihear, which requires explanation. Preah vihear temple border conflict between cambodia and. This article seeks to examine the provisional measures focusing particularly on the following issues. Temple of preah vihear gallery unesco world heritage centre. The ghosts of the temple of preah vihearphra viharn in the. This paper revisits the icj s original 1962 decision in the case of the temple of preah vihear, examining its legacy in the light of the 20 decision. In 1962, following a lengthy dispute between cambodia and thailand over ownership, the international court of justice icj in the hague ruled that the temple is in cambodia. Reading of the operative paragraph of the judgment the courts findings and vote, in english, by the president of the international court of justice. Preah vihear was situated in territory under the sovereignty of.
Bernhard kempen and zan he, the practice of the international court of justice on provisional measures. Cambodia protested and notified thai authorities that the temple was on the cambodian territory but thailand refused to withdraw its troops. This essay examines the 20 decision by the international court of justice interpreting its 1962 judgment in the temple of preah vihear case between cambodia and thailand, situating the more. Roots of thailandcambodia border dispute ubonwan yoosuk. Jul 24, 2019 preah vihear and the cambodiathailand borderland. Situated on the edge of a plateau that dominates the plain of cambodia, the temple of preah vihear is dedicated to shiva.
Temple of preah vihear, is that which is marked on the map of the. International court of justice year 20 20 11 november general list no. The international court of justice icj has never explicitly addressed cultural rights in its case law. Organs and agencies authorized to request advisory opinions.
Pdf this essay examines the 20 decision by the international court of justice interpreting its 1962. Summary of the judgment of the temple of preah vihear cambodia v. Its northern boundary forms part of cambodias international border with thailand and. The 20 decision, when read in isolation from the 1962 judgment, does not provide any indication that the original judgment was controversial. International studies perspectives, 10 3 southeast asia in the new international era. Search for library items search for lists search for contacts search for a library. Cambodia continued with the application for world heritage status and, despite official thai protests, on july 7, 2008, preah vihear temple was inscribed on the list of world heritage sites. Overview of the case cambodia complained that thailand had occupied a piece of its territory surrounding the ruins of the temple of preah vihear, a place of pilgrimage and worship for cambodians, and asked the court to declare that territorial sovereignty over the temple belonged to it and that thailand was under an obligation to withdraw the armed detachment stationed there since 1954. The temple gives its name to cambodias preah vihear province, in which it is now located, as well as the khao phra wihan national park which borders it in thailands sisaket province and through which the temple is most easily accessible. The icjs preah vihear decision and implications for regional dispute resolution. Towards a peaceful settlement of the preah vihear temple dispute.
Pdf the 20 judgment of the icj in the temple of preah. While having upheld its jurisdiction to adjudicate upon the dispute submitted by a first. Cambodia and thailand have been engaged in a territorial dispute over land in the vicinity of the temple of preah vihear, located near the countries shared border, for over ffty years. Affording a view for many kilometers across a plain, prasat preah vihear has the most spectacular setting of all the temples built during the sixcenturylong khmer empire. Modern asian studies, 32 4 thai and cambodia troops clash again on. Pdf the role of preah vihear in hun sens nationalism. Territorial issues in asia drivers, instruments, ways forward. Microsoft word preah vihear fact sheet correction word version eng. This paper looks at the judgment handed down by the international court of justice in november 20 on the interpretation of its 1962 judgment in the temple of preah vihear case between cambodia and thailand. Preah temple was an ancient and significant temple due to its cultural and historical value. Preah vihear province is,788 square kilometres big. On july 8,the world heritage committee decided to add prasat preah vihear, along with 26 other sites, to the world heritage site list, despite several protests from thailand, since the map implied cambodian ownership of disputed land next to the temple. Asian survey, 51 1 contemporary southeast asia, 27 3 paradigmatic faults in international relations theory. The temple, preah vihear, was the subject of a longstanding dispute between the two.
So cambodia brought on the grounds of the violation of its territorial sovereignty over the preah vihear temple and its vicinity the case before the international court of justice in 1959. In response to the political pressure at home, the thai government withdrew its formal support for the listing of preah vihear temple as a world heritage site. To adjudge and declare that the temple of preah vihear is situated in territory under the. From this, the judges concluded that bangkok had accepted the border and could not now question it ex post icj 1962. The temple is composed of a series of sanctuaries linked by a system of pavements and. Both countries have laid claim to a few square miles of scrubland around the temple since the. The icj adjudicated in this decree that the temple of preah vihear was. Its located in the north of the country and shares its international border to the north with thailand and laos, its provincial borders to the east with stueng treng, to the west with oddar meanchey and siem reap and to the south with kompong thom. Thailand, cambodia, border conflict, preah vihear, phra viharn. Preah vihear ruling hailed as winwin for thailand, cambodia. Dispute settlement of the thailand cambodia border stiftung. Cambodia protested and filed suit at the international court of justice icj five years later.
The conflict over preah vihear continued after the icj verdict. Pdf in 1962, the international court of justice ruled that the preah vihear temple lies within cambodian territory. Jul 02, 2019 cambodian government satisfied with icj ruling. International law uses of principle of equity, which is a principle of law used in civilized nation and international law adopted the same. Nov 11, 20 11 november 20 judgment request for interpretation of the judgment of 15 june 1962 in the case concerning the temple of preah vihear cambodia v. New phase of the temple of preah vihear dispute before the. Koh ker home to almost 30 ancient structures, including prasat thom, an immense seventier pyramid, koh ker was briefly the capital of the khmer empire under king jayavarman iv 92842. This essay examines the 20 decision by the international court of justice interpreting its 1962 judgment in the temple of preah vihear case between cambodia and thailand, situating the more recent decision in the context of the courts evolving role in asia. Jul 29, 2006 preah vihear river books guides english and thai edition vittorio roveda on. Europeans felt free to do what they liked with the antiquities for which no. Thus, the royal government of cambodia submitted a request to the icj to provide its interpretation of the 1962 judgment on preah vihear temple. Diplomatic relations were severed, and war was a real possibility. Prasat preah vihear travel northwestern cambodia, cambodia.
International court of justice icj decided that the possession of the preah vihear temple belongs to cambodia. Preah vihear cambodia v thailand merits, the icj decided in favour of cambodia. On july 7, 2008, preah vihear was listed as a unesco world heritage site. Latest developments temple of preah vihear cambodia v.
She further claims that the frontier line between cambodia and thailand, in the disputed region in the vicinity of the temple of preah vihear, is that which is marked on the map of the commission of delimitation between indochina and siam and that the temple of preah vihear is situated in territory under the sovereignty of the kingdom of. Explore prasat preah vihear holidays and discover the best time and places to visit. Honorary professor of the free university of brussels, advocate at the court of appeal of. From 8 july 2008 to 24 august 2009, a crisis took place for thailand and cambodia over an ancient temple located along their shared border. Phnom tbeng meanchey is the mountain rising to 600m 5 km southwest of tbeng meanchey town. The temple and the grounds are of considerable artistic and archaeological interest, and are potentially important militarily. Thailand invaded and captured preah vihear, prompting cambodia to file suit in the united nations international court of justice in the hague. The 20 judgment of the icj in the temple of preah vihear. Caso templo preah vihear by virginia mora reyes on prezi. Nov 12, 20 preah vihear ruling hailed as winwin for thailand, cambodia. See also request for interpretation of the judgment of 15 june 1962 in the case concerning the temple of preah vihear cambodia v.
Proceedings in the case concerning the temple of preah vihear, between cambodia and thailand, were instituted on 6 october 1959 by an application of the government of cambodia. This has, out of necessity, had an impact on the empowerment of cultural rights, enhancing their justiciability. Cambodias most dramatically situated angkorian monument, this 800mlong temple is perched atop an escarpment in the dangrek mountains elevation 625m with breathtaking views of lowland cambodia, 550m below, stretching as far as the eye can see. On 6 october 1959, the ministercounsellor of the royal cambodian embassy in paris handed to the registrar an application by the government of cambodia, dated 30 september 1959, instituting proceedings before the court against the government of the kingdom of thailand with regard to the territorial sovereignty over the temple of preah vihear. Thailand preah vihear witnessed by then siam minister of interior prince damrong rajanubhap photo by wikipedia damrong accepted as the court said, preah vihear and surrounding area belong to cambodia accordingly based on map drawn by 19041907 joint siamfrenchindochina border commission. World heritage angkor and beyond preah vihear gottingen. The red and yellow chasm inside thai society 1st ed. Henri rolin, honorary professor of the free vniversity of. Case concerning the temple of preah vihear cambodia v. While a newly independent cambodia sought to stand on its own, thai troops moved into preah vihear in 1954 to replace the departing french soldiers. In 1962, although the international court of justice icj awarded the temple to cambodia, but the frontier around the site remains in dispute. The red and yellow chasm the university of michigan press.
Pdf summary of the judgment of the temple of preah. The international court of justice icj, the principal judicial organ of the united nations, today rendered its judgment in the case concerning the request for interpretation of the judgment of 15 june 1962 in the case concerning the temple of preah vihear cambodia v. The primary objective of this paper is to disclose the imperfect account of states obligations provided for by the court. It borders the provinces of oddar meanchey and siem reap to the west, kampong thom to the south and stung treng to the east. Apparently it was since thailands government never protested the icj decision towards preah vihear temple. Cambodia and thailand will take their centuriesold border dispute back to the international court of justice from april 15 to 16, 20 to ask for. In its judgment of 26 may 1961, by which it upheld its jurisdiction to adjudicate upon the dispute submitted to it by the application filed by the. Vihears unesco induction with a free concert at phnom penhs. Thailand the temple of preah vihear is an ancient shrine situated on the borders of thailand and cambodia. Caso templo preah vihear pdf caso del templo preah vihear introduccion al caso. The temple of preah vihear is under the sovereignty of cambodia judgment of the international court of justice 15 june 1962 through its petition submitted to the international court of justice the court on 6 october 1959, the cambodian government requested that the court rule on a dispute over territorial sovereignty. International studies quarterly, 53 1 journal of alternative perspectives in the social sciences, 1 3 infinity journal, 1 4 a short history thailand ed. Cultural rights in the case law of the international court of. Icj ruling 6151962 on temple preah vihear cambodia vs.
928 681 1624 399 307 219 806 793 1601 156 1136 881 183 1036 1692 1673 862 336 1657 80 723 336 394 912 1639 456 762 203 1343 301 239 1451 1399 668 1090 1086